The primary public draft of the Seaport Type 10-12 got here out on Friday, I took a fast learn of it, listed here are some preliminary ideas that I will probably come again to because the spinoff approaches someday in Q3. Howard Hughes Holdings (HHH) goes to be spinning 4 fundamental property into the newly created Seaport Leisure (SEG) that may deal with “intersection of leisure and actual property”:
- The Seaport District in Decrease Manhattan, which incorporates the South Road Seaport itself, some neighboring buildings and the 250 Water St growth web site (which HHH/SEG lately gained a lawsuit that units the stage for development), all of which Howard Hughes has sunk over $1B into over the past decade and remains to be bleeding money (-$55MM in 2023). Up to now, the Seaport has been a catastrophe (HHH took a $672.5MM impairment on the Seaport final 12 months) and waste of capital, the undertaking was began a 12 months or two after Tremendous Storm Sandy destroyed a lot of the previous construction in 2012 and was underwritten at a 4-6% return on value. The event had many delays and hasn’t come near the unique profitability projections a decade or so later, as a long run HHH shareholder, I blame the Seaport for a lot of the underperformance over the past 5-7 years (alongside the Ackman covid capital increase). Perhaps centered administration can flip this round? There are a complete of 11 bodily buildings on the Seaport, as an entire it’s about 2/third’s leased at this level.
- 25% curiosity in Jean-Georges Eating places that was acquired for $45MM (doubtlessly an Ackman vainness funding) with the acknowledged technique to associate with Jean-George sooner or later as an anchor tenant in new developments (Jean-Georges leases all the Tin Constructing in a JV with SEG for a meals corridor idea). This funding jogs my memory of MSGE/Sphere’s funding in TAO Group the place they argued TAO’s nightclub experience may very well be used on the Sphere and different leisure venues, TAO was finally divested. The Jean-Georges funding feels very non-core and may very well be bought to boost capital for his or her two huge growth tasks (250 Water St and Style Present Air Rights).
- The Las Vegas Aviators (highest income grossing minor league workforce), the Oakland A’s AAA affiliate, and the corresponding newish Las Vegas Ballpark situated in Howard Hughes’ Summerlin grasp deliberate group. The A’s are shifting to the Las Vegas strip (the place the previous Tropicana was situated) in a pair years, the present plan is to maintain the Aviators in Summerlin, however TBD on how that impacts attendance/income. HHH did pay $16.4MM for the remaining 50% of the Aviators they did not personal in 2017 and the ballpark value roughly $125MM in 2019.
- 80% curiosity within the air rights above the Style Present Mall on the Las Vegas strip, which is situated on the north finish of the strip close to Treasure Island and the Wynn lodges. Howard Hughes has introduced in Anton Nikodemus because the CEO of Seaport, his earlier cease was because the President/COO of MGM’s Metropolis Heart in Las Vegas and earlier than that he led the event of MGM’s Nationwide Harbor and Springfield, MA casinos. I’m going yearly to a convention within the Metropolis Heart and have visited the Nationwide Harbor property, each are spectacular gaming resorts which might be effectively run. The Style Present Mall and the opposite 20% of the air rights are owned/operated by Brookfield Properties (which acquired Common Development Properties (GGP), the unique dad or mum of Howard Hughes). There’s been a big improve in provide on the north finish of the Las Vegas strip previously 12 months with the opening of Resorts World and the Fontainebleau (each of which post-opening are relative ghost cities). However with Nikodemus onboard, it clearly alerts that they intend to redevelop the Style Present Mall within the medium-to-long time period.
Every of those are a bit tough to worth and do not fairly match right into a typical public actual property firm (though HHH/HHC will nonetheless be a little bit of an odd ball public inventory following the spin, it helps on the margins). My query previous to the Type 10-12 launch was how this firm could be capitalized given it loses cash and sure will for the close to future, plus the plan is clearly to sink cash into their growth property, that query was answered with disclosure that Seaport intends to conduct a $175MM rights providing with Ackman’s Pershing Sq. backing it up plus money from HHC, giving SEG roughly ~$200MM in money at closing:
Seaport Leisure expects to conduct a $175 million Rights Providing of fairness to our stockholders following the distribution. In reference to the Rights Providing, the Firm is in critical discussions with Pershing Sq. Capital Administration, L.P. (“Pershing Sq.”), which by funding funds suggested by it’s HHH’s largest shareholder, concerning a possible backstop settlement which might be entered into previous to the distribution. Pursuant to that settlement, if finalized, Pershing Sq. would comply with (i) train its professional rata subscription proper with respect to the Rights Providing at a worth of $100 per share of our widespread inventory and (ii) buy any shares not bought upon the expiration of the Rights Providing on the Rights Providing worth, as much as $175 million within the combination. The backstop settlement might lead to Pershing Sq.’s affiliated funds proudly owning as a lot as % of our widespread inventory if no different stockholders take part within the Rights Providing. Any capital raised by the Rights Providing would additional strengthen our stability sheet. With over $ million of liquidity, primarily consisting of (i) $23.4 million of money contributed by HHH pursuant to the Separation Settlement, (ii) anticipated proceeds from the anticipated Rights Providing and (iii) quantities obtainable beneath the Revolving Credit score Settlement (as outlined herein), we consider we may have ample capital to put money into and drive inner and exterior progress alternatives within the leisure, tourism, hospitality, gaming, meals and beverage and stay leisure areas.
Rights choices can typically be juicy particular conditions (is that this a Greenblatt particular, spin + rights providing?), they arrive round not often, however typically sign a chance as a result of the corporate is providing all shareholders the chance re-up typically at a reduction.
The Seaport spin goes to be a problem to worth, cannot actually do a cap fee primarily based SOTP. HHH trades for 1.1x ebook worth at this level (regardless of holding quite a lot of land/buildings at historic value), HHH is the upper high quality asset, guessing Seaport will commerce at a reduction to ebook.
We do not know the spin ratio but, however at 80% of ebook, Seaport is roughly value ~$6-7 per HHH share previous to the rights providing, or about 10% of the HHH market cap. That probably means we see compelled promoting, may very well be an fascinating one to maintain on the watchlist.
Disclosure: I personal shares of HHH (fka HHC)
